At this point in the season it is a good question. In the month of May that is exactly what the Nationals have been. They have seemed to have found their footing and are playing competitive baseball. It does get tiresome repeating that over and over again but it is the truth and the team has looked downright competent at times. Lane Thomas and Jeimer Candelario have found their stride in May. Unfortunately those two are the top two trade candidates this coming deadline along with Trevor Williams and (fingers crossed) Patrick Corbin. I know Lane Thomas isn’t a free agent until 2026 but that is part of what makes him attractive and if you have an opportunity to oversell a Lane Thomas type you take it.
Accounting for the losses at the trade deadline some black magic is going to have to happen for the Nats to first get back to .500 and second to stay there. I do think that they will flirt with .500 at some point this season and quite honestly I wouldn’t be surprised if they stay there. What has to happen is simple. When they trade the players they are going to trade they have to replace them with players that are going to play that well or better.
In the case of Lane Thomas and Trevor Williams that is simple. Cole Henry is on a rehab assignment at AAA and pitching well and Robert Hassell III is at AA sporting a .400 OBP. If Hassell can get his hitting to match his batting eye then a promotion to the majors by the end of the season isn’t out of the question. We’ll definitely see him as a September call-up, and Cole Henry is likely to join the rotation even before the trade deadline.
The final piece of the puzzle is the most unlikely. First the July 9 draft has to fall the way as predicted and the Nationals take Paul Skenes and second he has to be as good as predicted and major league ready off the bat (pun intended). If that happens and those three players perform at the major league level then the Nationals have a very good chance of finishing at .500.
Let’s look at another scenario. This is a far fetched crazy thought but not that crazy given Mike Rizzo’s past of pulling a magic trade out of thin air. Let’s imagine the Nationals continue to play as they have and even have a hot June. By July they are flirting with .500 and spitting distance from a Wild Card position (they’re currently 3.5 games back but have 8 teams to leapfrog). So here it is the Nats are a game or two out of the Wild Card. They are sitting just a couple games under .500 but they aren’t about to trade any of the top prospects they just acquired and aren’t interested in any rentals. This works out to a Trea Turner trade type situation. The Nats wait, listen to the rumors, and when they see a team just not able to cross the finish line in a trade they, kindly, jump in to help. They offer to be the third team in the deal, and out of it they get a couple young major league pieces. Maybe one or two of the aforementioned players goes in a trade, but the Nats get players that help them now and in the future.
I hate when people throw out scenarios like this and don’t name names, and honestly it is an unlikely scenario. The first one is much more likely. The Nats get a little hot at home when it gets hot in June but still end up sellers and then don’t see a drop off in their level of play because of the players they promote. Either way this is going to be a fun season and I don’t think I’m going to get tired of saying that, at least as long as it remains fun.