The Washington Nationals and Trading for an Elite Starting Pitcher


I can’t help but think the rumors of the Nationals wanting an elite starting
pitcher are an example of the telephone game that gets played all off-season
between the media and their sources. Mike Rizzo tells an assistant that he
wants an effective starting pitcher and this is overheard and passed on to
someone else as an efficient starting pitcher and by the time it makes it to
the media the Nationals are looking to add an elite starting pitcher. There are
rumored to be two on the trading block right now in Max Scherzer and David
Price. Mike Rizzo was still with Arizona at the time Scherzer was drafted and
Nats fans know how much Rizzo likes to bring in players and personnel from his
Arizona days, but what would that trade look like?  

Figuring out what a trade for either
Price or Scherzer is difficult because a team like St. Louis could swoop in and
offer something like Wacha, Tavarez, and Wong and blow everyone out of the
water, but there is a strong chance that none of those players are close to available
in a trade which means more teams will be able to enter the bidding. As with
anything it is hard to know what exactly has to be paid when the price is a
mystery, but this reminds me of the last time I was in Arizona.  

Bryce Harper and Mike Trout were
dominating the headlines and the fields. Even at games they weren’t playing in
they were all anyone talked about, and I remember watching Bryce Harper and
how, even at 19, he appeared much bigger than any of the other prospects, but
Harper wasn’t the only Washington Nationals prospect I watched that fall. Derek
Norris was part of the Fall League that season and was still wearing a
Washington Nationals jersey. Shortly after the Fall League ended that season
Norris, along with AJ Cole, Brad Peacock, and Tommy Milone, was traded for
Gio Gonzalez. It has been a fair trade for both sides and might give us some
hint as to what it would take to get someone like Scherzer or Price. 

Both of the pitchers rumored to be on
the block this off-season are a step above where Gonzalez was at that time.
Gonzalez was viewed as a top to mid rotation starter whereas both Scherzer and
Price are viewed as league Aces, Price more so than Scherzer. Scherzer is going
to win the AL Cy Young this season, but he hasn’t been consistently in the
talks for the award season after season in the way Price has. He has had other
good seasons, but 2013 was his breakout and as with any breakout season the
question has to be asked, was this a breakout season or a career year?  

As far as what it would take for the
Nationals to get Scherzer or Price I do not think it will be anything but minor
leaguers. Both the Tigers and Rays would ask for Rendon, but it is doubtful
that any other team would offer something that good so he can be pulled back. Brian
Goodwin, who I am currently watching in the AFL and who has impressed me the
two times I’ve seen him, could be part of a deal. AJ Cole was recently listed
as the Nationals number one prospect by Baseball America and that is excellent
for his trade value. AJ Cole looks to be much more of a third or fourth starter
long term at the big league level and his best value to the Nationals could be
as part of a trade.  

There is a possibility that those two
as the center piece of the deal would be enough to make it happen or the Rays
or Tigers would insist on Giolito being included as well. At that point it
becomes wise to walk away. Not even the Royals gave up all three of their top
three prospects for James Shields. The third name will likely be someone still
in the top ten but not in the top five and then a name from the top 30 range.
At the end of it all I think that is how the trade will look no matter which
team Scherzer and Price end up on. 

The question still looming is do the
Nationals need to make this type of trade, and the answer to that is no. They
do not need a fourth Ace level starting pitcher and that is why I think this is
an example of a telephone game level of miscommunication or the Nationals
bandied about the word elite, but didn’t mean what we think they meant by the
word elite. Perhaps they want an elite innings eater like Bronson Arroyo or to
take a flyer on a pitcher who was once elite like Roy Halladay or Tim Hudson.
There are lots of possibilities for what was actually meant, and we won’t know
until something happens. The Washington Nationals don’t need another Ace in
their rotation to be successful in 2014 and further weakening the farm system
for 2015 and beyond could end up narrowing the window of opportunity to win a
World Series.    



/* Style Definitions */
{mso-style-name:”Table Normal”;
mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt;
mso-bidi-font-family:”Times New Roman”;